Peanut Butter S’mores Ice Cream

Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream Recipe from A Kitchen Addiction

Yesterday was my husband’s birthday and we made sure to celebrate with lots of dessert. . .Snicker’s cheesecake pie and ice cream! I forgot to get pictures of the pie, but I managed to get pictures of the ice cream before it was devoured. This peanut butter s’mores ice cream. I’m glad I did, because you will love this ice cream. It’s perfectly rich and creamy and filled with the iconic s’mores flavor!

Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream Recipe from A Kitchen Addiction

Instead of just using vanilla ice cream with marshmallows, chocolate, and graham crackers, I used toasted marshmallows and stirred in some creamy peanut butter. Toasted marshmallows give the ice cream an authentic s’mores flavor. No fire required. If you don’t want to take the extra time to toast the marshmallows, you can skip that step. But, I don’t recommend it, it’s well worth the extra time!

Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream Recipe from A Kitchen Addiction

The peanut butter makes the ice cream taste a bit like a s’mores made with a peanut butter cup. Which, if you haven’t tried that before, you need to try it soon. It’s the best! Add in chopped milk chocolate and crushed graham crackers, and you have a new favorite ice cream! Perfect for staying cool, satisfying your sweet tooth, and celebrating birthdays!

5.0 from 4 reviews
Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream
Serves: 1½ quart
  • 2½ C mini marshmallows, divided
  • 1½ C half & half
  • ¾ C heavy whipping cream
  • 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk
  • ½ C creamy peanut butter
  • ⅓ C chopped milk chocolate
  • ⅓ C crushed graham crackers
  1. Turn oven to broil. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a baking mat. Spread 2 cups of mini marshmallows on prepared baking sheet. Broil for 5 minutes or until marshmallows turn golden brown (or darker if your prefer). Remove from oven and allow to cool completely.
  2. In a food processor or a blender, pulse together toasted marshmallows, half & half, whipping cream, sweetened condensed milk, and peanut butter until marshmallows are completely mixed into milk mixture. Depending on the size of your processor, you made need to do this in two batches.
  3. Pour milk into ice cream maker and freeze according to manufacturer's instructions. Five minutes before finishing or when ice cream is soft-set, add the remaining ½ cup marshmallows, chopped chocolate, and crushed graham crackers and allow machine to finish churning. Serve immediately.
  4. If you want a harder ice cream, pour ice cream into a freezer safe container and freeze until desired texture is reached.

Easy Peanut Butter S'mores Ice Cream Recipe from A Kitchen Addiction

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. This sounds like all I need in life right now :)

  2. I became obsessed with s’mores using a Reese’s PB Cup last summer so I NEED to try this ice cream! It looks absolutely perfect for a summer night!

  3. OMG, this looks amazing! It’s only 8am in the morning but I want a big bowl of this peanut butter smores ice cream! :)

  4. I’ve never had peanut butter with a s’more and it sounds delicious! I love that you toasted the marshmallows because that’s my favorite part. :) This ice cream looks amazing!

  5. Happy birthday to your hubby! Sounds like you did celebratory dessert (it’s a thing :)) perfectly.

  6. happy bday to your husband! what a great flavor of ice cream…so creative :)

  7. I just love smores!!!

  8. I need an ice cream maker, it’s final! I’ve seen wayyyy to many bomb ice cream recipes like this one! Totally digging the flavors here girl! I’ve put PB in a s’more before and it’s unreal! So clearly i’d love this, right? Happy Wednesday :)

  9. Oh my gosh I love this ice cream. I just put my bowl in the freezer and I just might bring it out for this dish.

  10. Holy yum!!! This is one incredible sounding ice cream! I love it!

  11. I made pb s’mores ice cream for my birthday one year, definitely a great way to celebrate!

  12. You just made s’mores even better. Love this combo. Your hubby is a lucky man.

  13. Holy molly this looks amazing!!!

  14. S’mores with PB? This I can definitely get on board with! I find it weird that s’mores isn’t a thing over here. Need to rectify that!

  15. Wow he got some great desserts for his birthday!! I love it!! Love all the marshmallows in this ice cream I could go for a scoop or two now 😉

  16. Oooh I’m so excited, this looks like the best homemade ice cream. Your photography is gorgeous too!

  17. I’m seriously in LOVE with this. Best ice cream ever!

  18. OMG this looks so delicious!!

  19. That’s so cool that the marshmallow is in the milk mixture and little pieces throughout! Yum!

  20. Sooo when does the peanut butter come into play?? Can’t wait to make this for some dinner guests tomorrow!

    • So sorry for the delayed response, the comment somehow ended up in my spam folder! Thanks for catching that missing step! I’ve fixed the directions. You add it with the rest of the wet ingredients in the food processor/blender. I hope you enjoy it!

  21. It`s hard to go wrong with PB, chocolate, marshmallows, and graham crackers!! Plus, it`s ice cream. Which, in my book, is always a win.

  22. Oooh, this is so good! Love the toasted marshmallow addition, and that Snickers pie sounds pretty delicious too!

  23. Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says:

    Two scoops, please!! Pinning!

  24. Whenever I see an ice cream recipe I want an ice cream maker as well. So jealous and this looks so delicious! :)

  25. I’m gonna go out on a limb and say this might just be teh best ice cream flavor out there. Ever.

  26. Happy birthday to your husband!! And man, this looks amazing! Like a s’more with a peanut butter cup? Yes please!

  27. I wish it was my birthday tomorrow so you’d make this deliciousness for me!

  28. You and I are on the same page this week! I love that this ice cram is made without raw eggs!

  29. You just elevated s’more ice cream to a whole new level with the addition of the peanut butter! I’ll take a double scoop!

  30. This ice cream looks so, so good. I love smores and I love ice cream. This might be my new favorite ice cream flavor. Pinning!

  31. PB + S’mores are meant to be together. Happy Bday to your hubby! He’s lucky to have such a fabulous baker for a wife :)

  32. This looks fantastic! I love smores … and ice cream!

  33. This sounds SO GOOD!! I need ice cream, now!!

  34. Ooh! I love this idea- it’s like a fluffernutter-s’more ice cream! So many yummy flavors in each bite. Delish!

  35. oooooooooooooh girrrrrrrl!!! This ice cream is perfect. In everyyyy way! Love the pb and smores goodnesssssssss!

  36. Happy Birthday to your hubby! This ice cream sounds like the perfect celebratory treat! Pinned :)

Leave a Comment


Rate this recipe: